• Weather

    18° C Few clouds
  • Time

    03:03 AM
  • Wine average?

    95 Tb
  • Country Ranking?

  • Region Ranking?

  • Popularity ranking?




10th February, 2021 by Colin Hay

Terroir, history and context

There is little doubting the exceptional character of the terroir of Château Climens. And there is little doubting that the wine it produces, perhaps more so than any other leading cru of Bordeaux, is defined by its intimate connection to that terroir. Berenice Lurton is rightly proud of the late, great and much lamented Michael Broadbent’s suggestion that Climens is one of the two most consistent wines of Bordeaux – the other, of course, being Cheval Blanc.

She should be no less proud of the remarkable sensitivity to terroir that has made that possible. It is nowhere better exemplified than in the vineyard management and wine-making that she, her talented technical director, Frédéric Nivelle, and her entire team have put in place, above all since 2010 when Climens became biodynamic. There is, of course, a quiet concentrated passion and a singular determination present in each and every one of the leading wines of Bordeaux, but it is nowhere more viscerally present and more intensely focussed than at Climens. It is personified by Berenice Lurton, but it suffuses as it inspires and unites her entire team.

Yet there is an irony here. The name Climens was first used in connection with the lieu-dit in which

the château now stands in the mid 16th century. In the local dialect of the time it meant simply and literally ‘unfertile land’ (‘terre ingrate’). Nothing much grows. Or, at least, nothing much other than Sémillon – which, of course, thrives in wine-making terms in adversity. That is the secret of this terroir.

Its distinctive thin layer of red soil (the famous sables rouges de Barsac’) is a mix of sand and the clay formed from the erosion of the rock below. It is rich in iron oxide (hence its colour) and it sits on top of a limestone bed of crushed and calcified starfish (calcaire à astéries). Yet even in the context of Barsac, Climens’ terroir is unique, characterised as it is by an exceptionally thin topsoil and the presence of a network of faults in the rock below. The effect is almost optimal drainage reflected in turn in the brightness, complexity and purity of the fruit that ripens on its vines.

But this is not the only secret of this unique vineyard. For what is perhaps most interesting about its terroir is its capacity to impart a singular quality to Climens’ Sémillon. Sémillon, in the wines of Sauternes and Barsac, is typically something of a double-edged sword. Its susceptibility to noble rot (Botrytis cinerea), the sine qua non of Sauternes, makes it an essential (and, invariably, the major) component of practically every Sauternes or Barsac classed growth; but with the exception of Climens itself it is never present in mono-varietal


This is because of its tendency to produce wines that are heavy and lacking in vitality, freshness and acidity. Not at Climens; not at all.

Indeed, because – and only because – of the specific combination of its iron-rich red sandy soil and its limestone sub-soil, Climens produces the freshest, the most lifted and the most vertical wine of the entire region – and it does so exclusively from Sémillon. This is the paradox: all of the botrytic potential of pure Sémillon; all of the potential freshness of pure Sauvignon Blanc; made from pure Sémillon.

This makes Climens sound almost singularly blessed – and in a sense it is. But just as vines thrive in vinous terms in adversity, so Climens and the (relatively few) guardians of the secrets of its terroir have had to endure their fair share of adversity too.
The history of the property is long and complex. By the end of the 17
th century, Climens had, if not a Cháteau per se, then a country house with a chartreuse and 27 hectares of land. The majority of


this was planted with vines in three walled vineyards (or clos), the first of which was separated from the others by the buildings of what would become the Château.
chai was built during the 17th century at the same time as the rather beautiful well in the courtyard, with the two towers at each end of the logis added early in the 18th Century. It was during this period that, despite the difficulties of what was in effect a mini ice age, most of the labour of converting a relatively barren expanse of low-grade agricultural land into the vineyard that Climens was to become was achieved.

The French Revolution of 1789, however, brought all of this to an abrupt end, marking the transition to a much more difficult period. In 1800 the then owner, Jean-Baptiste Raborel (the last member of the family who had owned the estate since the 16th century) finally succumbed to a long illness, leaving a property so dilapidated that his widow had no choice other than to sell up. Climens was acquired by a Bordeaux négociant, for the relatively paltry sum of 40,000 francs in 1802 and then sold on quickly by him to the then mayor or Barsac, Éloi Lacoste. His almost 70-year tenure as the

guardian of Climens was something of a first glory period for the Château.


This culminated, in 1855, in Climens being declared Prémier Cru de Sauternes- Barsac in the official classification. But the good times were not to last for long. The property was sold in 1871 to Alfred Ribet, who needed all the bravery, courage and conviction for which he is now remembered. He continued to make improvements in the vineyard and wine-making at Climens, winning the coveted médaille d’or in Bordeaux in 1878. But tragically, and unbeknownst to him, phylloxera was already in the process of ravaging his vines. In 1885 he, in turn, was forced to sell the property to Henri Gounouihou and his wife, formerly

Mademoiselle Dubroca (the heiress to the smallest part of Chateau Doisy).

By this time three quarters of the vineyard had effectively been lost to phylloxera. A titanic process of reconstruction followed, first in the vineyard and then of the château buildings and the chai themselves. Not for the first nor last time in Climens’ history, steely determination and dogged persistence was rewarded. In 1900, only three years after the resumption in production, Climens was awarded a Grand Prix at L’exposition universelle de Paris, alongside the likes of Lafite, Latour Haut-Brion and Ausone.

This was the start of a second glory period for the château. The Gounouihou family ran

the domaine for almost a century, sharing their responsibility for most of that period with the same family of regisseurs, the Janin family.
In 1971 we enter a new period in the history of Climens, with the arrival of Lucien Lurton. He learned much from the Janin family who stayed on as 
régisseurs until the 1980s. Lurton bought the property at what was, again, a difficult time – not perhaps for Climens per se, but certainly for the wines of Bordeaux more generally and Sauternes more specifically (with a number of 1st growths changing hands during this period).

Wine (and, indeed, vineyard) prices were falling and an almost industrial style of vinification had taken hold with far too many properties sacrificing quality for yield. That would start to change, albeit slowly, from the 1980s, but largely thanks to visionaries, like Lurton, with the then rare combination of wine-making acumen allied with the passion and dedication that has so often proved the crucial ingredient in Climens’ history.

That precious combination is nowhere better exemplified than in his youngest daughter, Berenice Lurton, whose property Climens became in 1992. But even in this most recent period of the property’s history – a period in which the reputation and status of Climens has arguably been

elevated to previously unattained heights – things have not always been easy. Indeed, for Berenice Lurton things hardly got off to an auspicious start, with Climens making no wine at all in either 1992 or 1993. And in 2017 and 2018 the same thing happened again.

This was, of course, for rather different reasons – frost and mildew respectively, the latter so much more difficult to deal with in a vineyard which, by that time, had been tended biodynamically for almost a decade. Climens’ conversion to biodynamic winemaking began in 2010 and it was the first (and still only one) of the first growths to be certified biodynamic in 2014. As Berenice Lurton herself explained to me, the mildew damage in 2018 was almost like suffering a stroke – in that the mildew in effect savaged vines weakened by the frost of the year before. Appropriately, like the vines from which the wine is made, Climens is, as it always has been, a story of the triumph of endurance over adversity.

Climens’ market profile


Before turning in more detail to the wines themselves, it is perhaps first interesting to examine Climens’ place in the market today. Here, as for my earlier profiles ofBrane- CantenacBeychevelle Haut-Bailly, I am fortunate enough to be able to draw upon figures and data provided for me by Nicola Graham and Taylor Harrison at Liv-ex [https://www.liv-ex.com]. The first and perhaps the most important thing to say here is that, unlike any of the previous wines of Bordeaux that I have profiled in this series of articles, Climens is categorically not an investment wine. Nor are Sauternes and Barsac investment appellations.

But this is not to suggest that Climens is not an investment-grade wine. The issue here is, just as categorically, not one question of quality or grade. As the following analysis shows, there is absolutely no doubt about that. But what it is to suggest is that one cannot – and hence should not – buy classed growth Sauternes or Barsac (including Climens) looking for a return on one’s investment (certainly not, in today’s market, in the short to medium term).

That will probably come as no surprise to anyone reading this article, but it is important to be clear about this from the outset. Should any lingering doubt remain, Liv-ex’s data paints a pretty unequivocal picture on the subject. Just have a look at Figure 1.

This tracks and traces, over the last five years, the price movements of the last ten physical vintages of each of a number of leading Sauternes and Barsac prémiers crus, comparing that performance with that of the Liv-ex Fine Wine 100 index over the same time period.
For an investor holding physical stock of these wines 
– and, presumably, interested in the return on their investment – it does not make for very pleasant reading. Quite simply, any more conventional fine wine investment strategy would have yielded a significantly greater return that one featuring Sauternes and Barsac prémiers crus (notably Yquem itself); and what is true for the prémiers crus in general is even more pronouncedly so for Climens. Gauged solely in terms of investment potential, it is the worst performing of all.

But the operative word in the previous paragraph is ‘conventional’. For Climens, and by extension Sauternes and Barsac prémiers crus, simply do not feature in sane (let alone ‘conventional’) wine investors’ portfolios. These are – or, as Figure 1 suggests, they definitely ought to be – wines bought to drink (or, perhaps, to cellar with a view to drinking).


That makes sense, you might concede. But does it not make better sense to acquire one’s Climens only once it is ready to drink (given that it doesn’t tend to appreciate on the secondary market)? Well, yes, that would make sense too. But there is a potential hitch. For, precisely because Climens is not an investment wine and it is not made in great quantities either, it tends not to feature on the secondary market. It is typically bought, often en primeur, by those who will cellar it until they drink it. And that makes it difficult to acquire later. So whilst it is true that back vintages of Climens represent excellent value on the secondary market they may be difficult to find.

That, of course, brings us to a rather different way of looking at these wines. Investment grade but non-investment wines, like Climens, tend to share one rather attractive feature for the wine-lover (the ‘amateur’ as the French would put it) – they can, and typically do, represent remarkable value for money.

So how might we gauge that using Lix-ex data? There are a variety of strategies we could use. Here I pick two of the simpler ones. The first is just to look at the distribution of prices plotted against the published scores of leading critics (here the average current score of Neal Martin and Robert Parker). Figure 2 does exactly that.

It takes all of the Sauternes and Barsac prémiers crus in each vintage from 2007 to 2017, plotting the current (or most recent) Liv-ex market price against the average current score given to the wine by Neil Martin and/or Robert Parker. The red highlighted dots are vintages of Climens; those highlighted in yellow are vintages of Yquem.

The plot paints an interesting and eloquent picture which requires little analysis. It shows a number of important things very clearly. First, in price terms at least, Yquem is in an entirely different league to the other first growths, as its prémier cru exceptionnel status perhaps suggests. Ironically, it is in fact somewhat closer in price terms to the first growths of the Medoc (as we will see presently). Second, although Yquem is close to being in a league of its own in (perceived) quality terms too, it is less exceptional in qualitative terms than it is in quantitative (price) terms.

For, third and crucially, there is one other first growth consistently joining it in the same part of the qualitative spectrum. That, of course, is Climens. Put slightly differently, if one is looking for the quality of Yquem without having to pay the price of Yquem one’s options are limited to a single

wine. That wine is clearly and consistently Climens.

Finally, and perhaps surprisingly given this, Climens finds itself, almost regardless of vintage, on or below the best fit (or value) curve. As this suggests, it represents exceptional value for its critical acclaim amongst the prémiers crus even when Yquem is removed from the analysis.

A second way of looking at this brings the Medoc classed growths into the comparison. Here (see Table 1 below), and once again drawing on Liv-ex data, I calculate the average current market price (for 12 bottles in bond in sterling) for wines in a variety of (Robert Parker and Neal Martin) score brackets. The figures in parentheses are the number of cases of Climens in the same score bracket that one could purchase for the same outlay. This too makes for interesting reading.

Score range Medoc classed (RP, NM) Growths

Yquem Climens

99-100 5460 (5.33)

3520 (3.43) 1025

96-98 3065 (5.92)

2362 (4.56) 518

93-95 1386 (2.87)

2289 (4.74) 483

90-92 763 (1.58)

2000 (4.15) 482

87-89 612 (1.05)

— 585

84-86 410 ()


Table 1: Average price (per case, £, IB) for wines in various score brackets

(vintages 2000-2018 inclusive)

Source: Calculated from data supplied by Liv-ex

What it again shows is the remarkable value for money of Climens when placed alongside its most obvious natural competitor, Yquem, and the other wines of Bordeaux which, in qualitative terms at least, it most closely resembles.


Château Climens vertical tasting

The vertical tasting took place at the property itself on the 5th of January 2021. All of the wines presented were provided by the property itself. The wines were opened together and tasted from bottle, in flights of 3 or 4 vintages, from the youngest to the oldest. The tasting comprised 25 vintages of Climens spanning 5 decades. I am immensely grateful to Berenice Lurton, Frederic Nivelle and the entire Climens team for their welcome, their hospitality and their kindness.

First flight
Climens 2016
. Practically the same colour as the 2015 and 2014. Golden with slight, almost

crystalline, green highlights. Limpid and quite viscous. Predictably, this is more closed at first than any other wine of the tasting. But it is sublimely lifted and very vertical – like a firehose, charged with citrus fruit, pointed upwards in the mouth. And that verticality is so utterly and instantly representative of its terroir. There is a pronounced marine, saline, iodine minerality to this, almost like an Islay whisky.

Great volume, puissance and a radiant sense of energy. Fresh and dried flowers – celandine perhaps. But also a touch of toasted brioche and frangipane. So lively, so intense and yet so elegant. Citrus notes are predominant – both fresh and confit and the zestyness is accentuated by the salinity – as with fleur de sel. So light yet so powerful. Like a freeze-frame of a ballet dancer, this seems to defy gravity. A very special wine.

Climens 2015. A beautiful gold, with just a hint of green. More floral than the 2016, but with the same sense of lift and energy. Blossom, with more of a spicy element – turmeric and saffron. This is more obviously intense and powerful but it still retains that signature lift and freshness. Very energetic, poised and lively. Long and full. A touch of marzipan, a sprinkling of salinity accentuating the length like the grains of salt in aged Comte and, for the first but not the last time in the tasting, an intriguing almost petrol-note. Very harmonious, but not quite as complex as the 2016.


Climens 2014. The most citrus and the most floral too. Zesty, with every possible lemon, lime and grapefruit combination imaginable: tarte au citron; pink grapefruit sorbet, lemon posset, I could go on ... Lovely, taut and tight acidity. Very pure, precise and focussed and somehow that is even more beautiful as this is a more slender, elegant and refined wine than either of its younger siblings. Sappy, zesty and utterly joyful. Underappreciated, truly excellent and one of the revelations of the tasting. It is perhaps for drinking younger (though Climens evolves so glacially that this seems almost an irrelevance, other than that I wouldn’t hesitate to drink it now). Sublime in all its youthful beauty.

Second Flight
Climens 2013
. The most evolved of this second little flight of wines in both colour and on the palate. Very complex and rather different to the wines of the first flight. Butterscotch, caramel au laitcaramel au beurre salé; indeed, there is quite a pronounced ferrous salinity about this that cuts and brings tension to the sweetness. Orange marmalade, peaches and apricots, pain perdu (made

with brioche) and more classic English bread and butter pudding too. Lots of patisserie notes, with a hint of beurre noisette, almonds and frangipane.
This has a gorgeous mouthfeel, which is a little like the soft skin of a new season apricot plucked from the tree. And now that apricots are in my mind, they become the dominant fruit 
– in both fresh and slightly confit form. Saffron notes too, as in the 2015. This is a very active and dynamic wine that changes a lot with even a little air, offering so much complexity – those apricots again, now with a fresh note of wild flowers (fleurs des champs). Rich, but with plenty of balancing acidity and freshness, this is perhaps a little more Sauternes in personality.

Climens 2012. Tutankhamun gold (a phrase of Michael Broadbent’s that has always stuck with me, that I love and that I know he used of Climens 1983 in its comparative youth). This is beautiful and not just visually. Rich and buttery on the nose – toastedbriochewith salted butter. Apricots, reine claude plums and mirabelles, white nectarine skin too; straw and dried herbs. Pure and eloquent. Frangipane and patisserie notes with toasted and crushed almonds too. This is simpler than the 2013, a little more direct and less delineated, thinner too and with a very slight harshness on the finish. But it is very harmonious and complete, with lovely balance and integration. I pick up again, that interesting hint of petrol (as with the 2015 and 2004). And I love the freshly cut lilies that seem to gather in the glass with more air.

Climens 2011. A wine I have had the good fortune to taste a number of times now, with very similar (mental and written) notes. A touch of white chocolate, lemon zest, lemon meringue pie and confit quince with a pronounced saline minerality. The most floral of the second flight too. Intensely lifted, lithe, energetic and poised. This has a hidden power about it that reminds me a little of Yquem. It is more disguised than the other wines of the tasting thus far, an impression reinforced by the silky texture.

Deep, profound and palpably cool on the palate, with an almost lemon menthol freshness. Plunge

pool – the Pichon Lalande of Sauternes and Barsac – with a similar sense of gothic depth and mystery. It is a little like walking into a crypt, with one’s senses put on alert and the hairs standing up on the back of one’s neck. So beautifully well integrated and lithe. Above all, such a lovely shape and texture. Tranquil and exquisitely balanced.

Third flight
Climens 2010
. The first vintage made biodynamically (although 2014 is the first to receive biodynamic certification). Light gold, with just a touch of amber. Lemon curd, lemon zest, lemon marmalade – indeed, 50 shades of lemon! Frangipane, Bergamot, flint and a slight struck match note, saffron once again. Very fresh and lifted and very much at the top of the palate. Rich and incredibly complex, quite stunning actually even in this line-up. Toasted brioche and patisserie. But also hyacinth and exotic spicy notes – turmeric and nutmeg and, rarely for Climens, some more exotic fruits notes – mango, fruits confits and angelica. Very tense and lively and very youthful – it actually needs a little more time in bottle to knit together. Fantastically complex, very intellectual, incredibly dynamic and, one feels, in transition to its next evolutionary stage.

Climens 2009. Tasted a couple of times in recent months, with very similar notes. Beeswax and candles – big ones, think Notre Dame or St Pauls! Fruits confits; dried flowers and pot pourri. Lifted. Sunny, warm, rich, easy, opulent, sensuous. But at the same time, and in an archetypically Climens way, lifted and with a luminous bright freshness that really sets it apart.

Fantastic texture – so round and opulent and rich with not a single discordant note; and then a firehose of fresh zingy citrus sensations. Very sappy. Little hints of burnt sugar bitterness – toffee apple, caramal au beurre salé, the crème brulée crust one craves. Floral, lifted (I know I’ve said it already but it somehow needs repetition as one it struck by it again and again), and very mineral. Quite simply, brilliant.

Climens 2008. A little darker, more gold than amber still, but just starting to shade that way. Truffles, for the first time, and cedar too. This is interestingly resinous and has a fascinating combination of marine/saline and more caramelised notes – the conversation around the table settles on a carapace of lobster or langoustine (the crustaceans well coloured and deglazed with

Cognac). Lemon marmalade, beurre noisette, caramel. Pure and rich if less intense than the other wines in this flight at least. Though my notes keep bringing me back to sweet elements (I pick up butterscotch and apricot conserve on the finish), the fresh acidity is palpable, giving this an exquisite sense of tension and yet balance.

Fourth flight
Climens 2007
. Gosh, wow, this is a revelation – in that it more than exceeds the very elevated expectations I had for it. Just wonderful. Somewhere between gold and amber, but still remarkably youthful and hence rather closer to the former than the latter. Truffles, again. Apricot, white nectarine, peach, pear and quince, with a little hint of beeswax. There is a touch of bitter marmalade but predominantly the fruits are zingy and fresh. A couple of us pick up an interesting earthy, rooty element.

Cool, composed and yet incredibly powerful with the most exquisite texture and a sense of calm tranquillity (reminding me a little of the 2011, at least in that respect). We are back in the crypt. Or the plunge-pool. This is very noble and it’s a wine that requires intense concentration. It is slightly mysterious, slightly impenetrable, slightly introvert and, like the 2001, it really rewards patience and focus. Very special and, for me, on a par with the 2001.

Climens 2005. This actually appear slightly more youthful still than the 2007, with just a shade less amber. This is much less introvert, more obviously powerful and very grand and very rich – more 2009 than 2010. Dried flowers, pot pourri, a touch of saffron and those frangipane and patisserie notes. This is cut from the same cloth as the 2013 and 2008 – in that it is much more direct and much more extrovert. The botrytis is beautifully radiant and this is big, rich, classic and bold. Le Roi de soleil with, appropriately enough, a lovely sunny saffron note on the long and tapered finish. The contrast with the 2007 is fascinating.

Climens 2004. More obviously sweet with a lovely bitter twist of burnt sugar. That petrol element that is also there in the 2015 and the 2012. Confit and fresh pineapple (quite rare in Climens), with coconut, almonds and macaron. Very pure and precise especially in the mid-palate and more delicate than the other wines in the flight. This finishes very long, but is focussed very much on the very top of the palate. Luminous, vibrant, racy and bright though less powerful than the previous wine; delicate and quite refined with that, oh so important, freshness from start to finish.

Fifth Flight
Climens 2003
. Very youthful in hue and in fact slightly lighter than the 2002. You would never pick this as from 2003 in a million years. This is very floral – a mix of dried and fresh flowers in fact, most notably for me elderflower. Mango, guava, pineapple, pomelo and fresh quince. Nice citrus notes and a marked lift and a zingy freshness that I have never encountered in Sauternes or Barsac of this vintage before. Nutmeg and a little cinnamon too; Jasmin, Bergamot and a suggestion of fresh green tea leaves. Rich and with a lovely balance. Incredible for the vintage and exceptionally difficult to pick as 2003. The secret here is the lift and verticality that comes from the limestone subsoil.

Climens 2002. Gold much more than amber. So youthful and wonderfully aerial, lithe and extremely lifted. Very fresh, but dense and powerful too. The texture is sublime, so soft and caressing, especially on the attack. It opens on the palate in two waves, the first cool and super- svelte, the second more architectural with the acidity almost chiselling out the structure.

There are similarities here with the 2007, both in terms of the structural complexity in evidence here and the slightly introverted and impenetrable character of this rather intellectual wine. Very long on the palate and very complex, with floral notes, hay, a hint of truffle and a lovely sappy, zesty finish – confit lemon; lemon mousse; lemon merinque pie. Very different from the vintages either side, though with elements of both.

Climens 2001. The star of the show, but actually quite restrained and more introvert than extrovert. Not quite what I was imagining, but every bit as good. This is powerful but not at all showy. Indeed, it’s rather reserved in its almost stolid perfection. But what it has in abundance is energy. It is tense and charged, bright and vibrant, radiant and luminous and with the most utterly sublime texture.

And it is, of course, extraordinarily complex: fresh crunchy apples, toffee apples, dried flowers, mirabellesconfit saffron, quince, every form of citrus imaginable (fresh, confitpressé, preserved), frangipane, almond purée ... Incredible power yet so held back too –a puissance so incredibly finely and gently released. A monumental wine that produces goose pimples up and down the spine. Tense, energetic and with something viscerally spiritual about it. Remarkable and very, very special indeed (if quite exhausting to taste when taking notes!).

Sixth flight
Climens 1999
. More amber than gold, but like every wine in the flight, remarkable youthful at 21 years of age. The first impression is that this is intensely floral – fresh spring flowers not at all what one expects in a Sauternes or Barsac of this kind of age. Marmalade, fruits confit, angelica and marzipan. A little slender, though that is no doubt accentuated by coming immediately after the 2001. Fresh, nicely integrated and harmonious. Quite simple, slightly austere but fresh and actually less sweet than most of the wines of the tasting.

Climens 1997. A beautiful amber robe. The first bottle is corked, the second is glorious. Floral, again. Energetic; lifted; lithe; almost chewy. Turkish delight; truffles too (not necessarily things one expects to find in the same glass). Excellent. The best of this flight. Extremely floral and spicy too – saffron and turmeric especially. Luminous, radiant and its verticality and florality combined almost make one think that it forms the shape of a flower in the mouth.

Climens 1996. Lighter in hue and amazingly youthful. Not quite in the same league as the the 1997. Lacks a little definition in the mid-palate and also the energy of many of these wines. Saffron, citrus and petrol notes; a hint of liquorice root. A very pretty wine, but lighter and shorter than practically every other vintage we have tasted. According to Berenice Lurton, the 1996 is something of a Diva – often sublime, but sometimes a little temperamental. We seem to have caught her (the Diva that is) on a less expressive day.

Climens 1995. The lightest in colour of the flight, though the oldest (at a more 26 years of age). The nose is quite distinctive and a little different: a little soapy at first, but that clears. Dried petals, roses, Palma violets, Turkish delight and fresh almonds. This has a lovely sense of integration and harmony, but lacks a bit of mid-palate concentration in comparison with the younger vintages. The slightly ferrous, salty minerality is, however, sublime. Candyfloss, roses, lemon sorbet and mixed nuts with a touch of spice – indeed, pain d’épice. Quite delicate and very pretty. Intriguing.

Seventh Flight
Climens 1990
. Amber – and the darkest of this famous trio of vintages at Climens. Limpid, gloriously so, and with great viscosity. Utterly glorious and very flattering. Marmalade., toffee apples, caramel au beurre salebeurre noisette. Floral, but in a slightly different way – the scent of bulbs more than flowers per se. Fresh; lithe; sappy; vertical and very ‘Climens’ even in this archetypally Sauternes vintage. With a little more air, divine scents of Seville oranges. Wow! So fresh and delicious. This is a wine one reacts to almost more physically than intellectually. It is in the same vein as the 2009 and 2005 and it offers a window, perhaps, onto their future.

Climens 1989. The lightest of the flight, as 1989s tend to be, and my favourite of the trio. So very floral: rose petals and peonies. The freshest and liveliest of these. Young, like its colour. So supple and soft and bright and yet elegant and delicate. Brilliant. A little like the 2007 and 2011 in personality. Sprightly. Bright. Vibrant. Sparkling. There are fireworks going off all over the place – and there is even a note of the freshly struck match, maybe even cordite! So amazingly zingy and long. Undoubtedly one of the wines of the entire tasting. Noble and natural. Remarkably intense. One of very few wines to have brought a tear to my eye.

Climens 1988. In the glass this looks very like the 1990. Amber. Marmalade and the bitter yet intensely sweet exterior of a toffee apple; cracked burnt sugar. In personality, somewhere between the 1990 and the 1989. There are fireworks, but they are quieter and more sedate (Catherine wheels rather than rockets!). In a way this is purer and more precise but a little less complex, though with the same sense of internal harmony. It is fresh, like the other two. But what I love here are the

mushroom notes – dried black tropette de la mort. Sappy, a little edgy with the fresh fruitiness of lemon and orange zest and a little hint of tobacco.

The final flight

Climens 1977. Amazingly youthful in appearance. We are back to Tutankamun gold with yellow highlights. Truffles and dried wild mushrooms, with a little hint of sous bois. Lifted. This is very glossy on the front of the palate, if a little dry on the finish. An amazing wine from an ‘off’ vintage (there are clearly no such things at Climens). Quite savoury, but with the lovely freshness of pure but concentrated lemon, confit lemon and tarte au citron with a hint of cinnamon and vanilla. Most 2003 prémiers crus Sauternes are darker in the glass than this, and few taste as youthful!


Climens 1975. A shade more towards amber. Slightly closed at first – but opens nicely gradually with a little air. There is lovely integration on the nose. Classic sweet shop aromas intermingled with citrus and orange notes; less floral than most. This is a little bit old school, though much less so than the 1969. But the signature freshness and lift of Climens is there. Burnt sugar and candyfloss, Seville orange marmalade, mandarin zest. The finish is interesting – a little bitter with a note of burnt sugar but also an intriguing hint of peppermint, spearmint and eucalyptus.

Climens 1971. The first Lurton vintage of Climens. Somewhere between the 1975 and the 1977 in colour – but closer to 1977. In other words, remarkably youthful once again. Orange zest, Turkish delight, crepes suzettes and, strangely perhaps, wild strawberries too. Light and lifted. Not really very powerful in an objective sense, yet this has a deceptive suave underlying richness and intensity. Delicate yet impressively grand. Long and salty. On the palate this is a wandering path with precision, but not linearity (a snake, as it were). Very elegant and very youthful with an almost hypnotic charm. Fascinating notes of black pepper, cardamom, cinnamon, nutmeg and mint leaf.

Climens 1969 (Gounouihou). The final wine of a remarkable tasting and the only one that predates the arrival of Lucien Lurton in 1971. This is darker – true amber – and has something of the old dark, slightly dank cellar about it on the nose at first, though that clears with a little air. This is just beginning to break up and is a little oxydised on the finish. Earthy and loamy and just slightly rustic but in a rather charming way. Tobacco leaf and an almost slightly lactic note. Cinnamon (which comes through with air and blows away the old cellar notes) and nutmeg. Orange marmalade too. Lovely in an old-world way. A note of grain whisky about it and cocoa too. A wine with a profound sense of place and history.

Wines of the tastingOther highlights:

Climens 1989, 20012007, 2009, 2010, 2016 Climens 1988, 1990, 1997, 2005, 2009, 2011, 2014 Climens 1969, 1977, 2002, 2003

Exceeding expectations:
Colin Hay is Professor of Political Science at Sciences Po in Paris where he works on the political

economy of Europe, La Place de Bordeaux and wine markets more generally.

Liv-ex is the global marketplace for the wine trade. It has 475 members in 42 different countries, that range from start-ups to established merchants. Liv-ex supplies them with the tools they need to price, source and sell wine more efficiently. It also offers data-only packages for producers and châteaux who want access to Liv-ex data, but don’t need to trade on the global marketplace.




2015 : Early, fast and outstanding harvest! / The beginning of October is much more quiet than usual at Château Climens : seldom a harvest has finihed so early!  After a longer and bigger than expected first period, due to very good climatic conditions, the picking did stop shortly between September 22 and 28. The golden grapes were slowly becoming mauve under the effect of Botrytis when a succession of sunny and windy days dramatically accelerated the process of concentration. The harvest started back for what proved to be the last straight line: 8 consecutive days of quick but meticulous picking, giving rise to a superb and abundant crop. This early and fast picking enabled us to avoid both the effects of overconcentration and those of the coming  rainy weather: right from October 5th, all the crop was under cover in the cellar, slowly but surely fermenting in barrels.

2015 : Early, fast and outstanding harvest!

Thanks to biodynamics, the vineyard did fully benefit from the very favourable climatic circumstances leading to early maturation of the grapes, followed by perfect development of noble rot in September.

After 3 years of meager yields, our 20 hl per hectare of great quality remind us of the bountiful crops of the 2009-10-11 trilogy.

The aromatic purity and finesse of the musts, their excellent balance (potential 21.5° as an average), the consistency of the lots predict a superb Chateau Climens!

Read More


The exceptionally distinguished Château Climens, whose outstanding past spans several centuries, became known as the “Lord of Barsac” very early on. The history of this prestigious growth is characterised by unfailing continuity enabling only the very best to be coaxed out of this unique terroir. At the same time, it has meant that ongoing upkeep and perfection of its ancestral heritage is possible.

Only five families have owned the estate from its origins. This is a rare occurrence which explains why its surface area in a continuous single vineyard has practically remained unchanged since the date of its creation.

The name Climens appeared for the first time on a contract dated 1547, in which it is stated that Girault Roborel, the King’s advocate in Barsac, had inherited a part of this land from his father. The two names, Climens and Roborel, would soon become one family name, the Roborel de Climens family who built up the domain over more than two centuries. An elegant, discreet Chartreuse (traditional local architectural style home) built in the 17th century is a telling indication of the domain’s distinguished past. However, historical unrest would get the better of this joint venture and the well established domain was damaged during the French Revolution. The widow of Jean-Baptiste Roborel de Climens sold it in 1802.


Jean Binaud who bought it knew what he was doing: a Bordeaux wine merchant, he recognised the potential of this property and took great care of it. Thereafter Château Climens belonged to two more families of wine makers who were equally conscious of the value of this unique terroir. It is therefore no surprise that Château Climens was granted First Growth status in 1855. From 1855 the famous printers and journalists from Bordeaux, the Gounouilhou family, took over Climens and kept it for almost a century. In the early 1970s Lucien Lurton started taking an interest in the Sauternes region. This man who is passionate about exceptional terroirs already owned several famous classified growths in the Medoc. He was won over by the finesse of the Climens wines and with great foresight acquired the Château in 1971 despite the crisis that Sauternes wines were undergoing at the time. He brought a determined touch of modernity as well as relentlessly high standards to the domain while respecting both tradition and the centuries-old savoir-faire in particular. It was in 1992 that his daughter Bérénice Lurton took the Château’s destiny into her capable hands. Since then, it is with enthusiasm and determination that she takes great care in perpetuating the precious magic of Château Climens, ensuring that this legendary growth shines with evermore brilliance and grace.

Read More


On the left bank of the Garonne, an enclave within the Graves region in the south-west of Bordeaux, the Sauternes-Barsac appellation is a tiny region where the most prestigious sweet white wines in the world are made. The Grands Crus from Sauternes and Barsac were classified in 1855 at the same time as the Grands Crus from Médoc. Château Climens belongs to the First Classed Growths of 1855.


Within the Sauternes appellation, the village of Barsac is the only one to benefit from its own appellation: its terroir, with a predominance of limestone gives different wines, often less opulent than those from Sauternes, but generally endowed with greater freshness in terms of balance and aromatic expression. The Barsac vineyard stands out across the heart of the rolling landscapes of the Gironde. Dry stone walls echo the rows of vines, indicating the four enclosures of Climens that surround the château’s 30 hectares situated on the appellation’s highest land where limestone outcrops are abundant.

Read More


Climens is a wine with a very strong and bewitching personality. Every deed and gesture in our complex profession of being a viticulturist and wine maker are relentlessly aimed at this target: to bring out the special grace that is specific to Climens and which so many passionate wine lovers fall in love with – to bring this out year after year, beyond and through the differences of each vintage.

The philosophy of Château Climens: crafting wines like a true goldsmith

In creating the wines we seek the special grace that only the terroir at Climens can produce. It is a harmonious and magical wine that takes flight and remains weightless.”


Read More

Inside information

The name Climens means ‘unfertile or poor land’ in a local dialect! That was not taking into account the vine, this prodigious plant which is capable of transforming apparently undesirable soils into terroirs blessed by the gods. Their red soils, a thin layer of clayey sand rich in iron, cover a fossil-rich limestone platform which favours natural drainage.

From a biodynamic point of view, great terroir is born of balance among the four elements: Earth, Water, Air and Fire. At Climens one’s eye is drawn to the red earth that originates in Fire and is the guarantor of richness. The element Water, found in the clay, balances this natural opulence perfectly by endowing the wine with its fluidity and freshness. The climate is different every year and whether it is the rain or the heat, Water or Fire in varying proportions, it makes each vintage unique.

However, Climens is above all an airborne, weightless wine, devoid of any heaviness. It is the really unusual sands which give it the Airelement, guaranteeing the brightness, the elegance and the taut tension that are so characteristic of Château Climens. The limestone which represents the Earth element brings structure and depth to it.

But in order to attain the perfect balance, generations of wine makers have realised that it was necessary to transcend the limestone with a grape variety characteristic of Earth. And so it has been Semillon that imposed itself over the centuries as the one and only variety at Climens. It asserts the originality of the cru as a virtuoso interpreter of this exceptional terroir and is a tremendous vector for Botrytis Cinerea.

With a helping hand from the micro-climate, the ultimate paradox can take place: the arrival of noble rot, which veritably sublimes this natural harmony that one calls the soul of a wine. 

Read More

2 different wines with 85 vintages


Latest news

WINERY NEWS Château Lafleur / “Twenty twenty-one has a multi-vintage profile; it is difficult to summarise. It was key to re  more ...
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS BWW 2022 – The Best Wine Critics of the World  / TOP 30
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS BWW 2022 – The Best Wine Critics of the World have been selected  / Jeb Dunnuck is the surprise Winner!
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS 100 BEST CHAMPAGNES 2022 / by Champagne Magazine and Tastingbook.com
WINERY NEWS Cloudy Bay / Cloudy Bay defies NZ shortage to release two new Sauvignon Blancs Despite confirmed shortages of   more ...
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS Anthony Barton, Legendary Bordeaux Winery Owner, Dies at 91 / A dashing figure for decades in the wine trade, he raised châteaus Léoville Barton and Langoa Barton to iconic status
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS Gérard Basset Foundation announces 14 funding grants to fuel diversity in the wine industry / The Trustees of the Gérard Basset Foundation have awarded funding grants to 14 institutional and community partners to fund diversity wine education programmes after raising over £1,200,000 at the Golden Vines awards ceremony and related auctions.
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS Harlan Estate and BOND appoint Kerry Wines as China distributor / Napa Valley icon Harlan Estate and BOND, pet project of Harlan’s owner Bill Harlan, have announced a partnership with Kerry Wines to be their distributor in China.
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS 100 Years of Jaboulet | A Connoisseur’s Collection | Finest & Rarest Wines / At the conclusion of a momentous year for Sotheby’s Wine, our London team is delighted to present our final auction before Christmas with: 100 Years of Jaboulet | A Connoisseur’s Collection | Finest & Rarest Wines.
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS The top traded wines in 2021 / by Liv-ex
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS Champagne’s best year to date / Despite a slightly diminished share of trade, 2021 has been an excellent year for Champagne.
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS The Fine Wine Market in 2021 / All previous records set in 2020 have been broken and surpassed in 2021, marking the most successful year ever for the secondary fine wine market.
WINERY NEWS Château Rieussec / The art of Metamorphosis Imagining the consumption of Sauternes by positioning it as an accompani  more ...
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS France has smallest harvest since 1957 / his would be the third consecutive year where the global production level is below average
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS Château Mouton Rothschild unveils the label for its 2019 vintage / illustrated by Olafur Eliasson
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS Angélus and Cult Wines explore NFT trend / An emerging trend in the collectibles market has made further inroads in wine via the release of a ‘non-fungible token’ linked to a barrel of Château Angélus 2020 and a digital artwork of the St-Emilion estate’s famous golden bells.
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS Experimental Harlan's Napa red launches in Hong Kong / A red Cabernet blend, created by Domain H. William Harlan, and not originally intended for sale, will debut in Hong Kong through leading wine importer Omtis Fine Wines.
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS Vega Sicilia Moves into Rías Baixas / .
TASTINGBOOK WINE NEWS Record-Breaking Wine Sale At 2021 Hospices De Beaune Auction To Fight Against Female Violence And Breast Cancer / With a new auctioneer, the historic event sold barrels of 2021 Burgundies to raise $15.3 million for health care and women's charities

Wine Moments

Here you can see wine moments from tastingbook users.    or    to see wine moments from your world.

 Château Climens  has news

BORDEAUX PROFILE: CHÂTEAU CLIMENS 10th February, 2021 by Colin Hay Terroir, history and conte  more ...

1y 1m ago

 Jürg Richter / Sauternes Expert, Wine Writer (Switzerland)  tasted  34 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  58 wines 

Château Climens 1921 / Crème bulée, molasses but still quite dominant acidity. Apple pectin, vanilla and plum compote. Long, elegant finish. 19 points

1y 1m ago

 Juha Lihtonen / The Best Scandinavian Sommelier 2003, Pro (Finland)  tasted  1 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  185 wines 

BWW2021 competition finals were filled with superb lineup of the world's greatest wines and superb finds from various price categories. The finals that were run in various blind tasting sessions, revealed many surprises. Most commonly, the fact that all the wines were so enjoyable already at this young stage, although many of them will deliver so much more after ageing of 10-15 years. Congratulations for all the winners!

1y 6m ago

 Christer Byklum , Wine Writer (Norway)  tasted  1 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  22 wines 

1964 Chateau Latour;Dark ruby, brick rim. B/C level fill, soaked cork. Liquorice, sweet tobacco, hay, some blackcurrants, gorgeous nose, some ripe tannins still, fresh acidity, quite intence, extremelly complex, almost at such a degree, that you can't decipher it all, perfect structure, truly impressive, and exceptionaly long finish. 96

1y 7m ago

 Clive Coates / MW, Wine Writer (France)  tasted  1 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  41 wines 

Montrachet, 2002 Domaine Des Comtes Lafon.
Montrachet, please notice. No Le, as the plot is on the Chassagne side. Here was a wine which took its time to come out of the glass. At first I was a little underwhelmed, but after ten minutes or so, the richness, concentration, and indeed a succulence almost like a red wine, began to appear. We have something which is quite oaky, still quite youthful, full bodied and very classy indeed: the depth unmistakably of a grand cru. Quite splendid!

1y 9m ago

 Julia Harding MW, Wine Writer (United Kingdom)  tasted  1 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  27 wines 

Telmo Rodríguez Lanzaga 2009 / Bushvine Tempranillo, Graciano and Garnacha from the village of Lanciego. Planted at 500-600 m on a sandstone plateau. Flat shallow soils, stony, calcareous and silty textured. Low fertility and low water retention capacity. Some fruit from own biodynamically farmed vineyard, some bought in. 40,000 bottles. Fermented with native yeasts in cement tanks, matured 14 months in big oak casks and smaller barrels. Bottled June 2012.
Intensely dark crimson with black core. Smells immediately sweeter and riper and more intense than the LZ, with some oak sweetness. Very dark fruited and more spice too. Even with that extra fruit intensity there is still a graphite/mineral dimension. On the palate, the tannins are dense but somehow silky at the same time, giving a wonderfully dry finish, the same effect as 70% dark chocolate but with a different flavour. Still pretty closed up on the palate, dark and savoury and firmly mineral. Super-dry, long finish. So much more to come. Stunning wine. A little more luscious than the 2010 Alto Lanzaga. (JH)

1y 10m ago

 Markus Del Monego MW/BWW2022-Best Germany Wine Critic of the World, Wine Writer (Germany)  tasted  2 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  2 wines 

Bérénice Lurton has a great reputation for producing some of the world's finest botrytised wines. She converted Château Climens, a Premier Cru Classé in Barsac, in a biodynamic property and has set new benchmarks in the Bordeaux universe. Her idea of producing a dry white wine, based on the Semillon grape, was realised with the vintage 2018. Pascal Jolivet, the famous wine producer from the Loire Valley, her consultant for the biodynamic conversion already, was teaming up with her for this new style of wine. The result is impressing and proves, that great dry wines can be produced in Barsac too.

2y 12d ago

 Neal Martin/BWW2022 - Best Bordeaux Wine Critic of the World, Wine Writer (United Kingdom)  tasted  1 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  25 wines 

The 1961 Palmer is a wine that tends to deliver upon its gargantuan reputation and we were rewarded with an exemplary bottle here. It has a clear colour with modest bricking on the rim. The bouquet is difficult to encapsulate into words – utterly ethereal. Heavenly definition, almost Burgundy-like in purity with traces of pencil box and pressed violets. It grows in stature with each swirl of the glass and leaves you transfixed. The palate is bestowed beguiling balanced, almost symmetrical, framed by filigree tannin and pitch perfect acidity. Like the aromatics it coheres with aeration, the fruit undiminished by time even if it is no blockbuster. Quite the opposite – this 1961 Palmer is the apotheosis of finesse with just a hint of balsamic on the aftertaste. This Margaux can bring you to tears of joy. Tasted at the 1961 dinner Chairman Miaow’s in Hong Kong.

2y 4m ago

 Jürg Richter / Sauternes Expert, Wine Writer (Switzerland)  tasted  2 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  10 wines 

Château Filhot 1929 / Bitteres Caramel. Schöne melassige Süsse. Bittermandeln und Amaretto. Gute Säure. Dicht und lang. Mit dem 1929er die grosse Sensation bei Filhot. 

2y 5m ago

 Julia Harding MW, Wine Writer (United Kingdom)  tasted  1 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  25 wines 

Henschke Hill of Grace 2004 / 100% Shiraz grapes from pre-phylloxera material brought from Europe by the early settlers in the mid-1800s and grown in the Eden Valley wine region. Matured in 100% new French (50%) and American (50%) hogsheads for 18 months prior to blending and bottling.
Slightly greyish but deep garnet. Intensely sweet dark cassis fruit plus some cedary leafy notes. Rich and smooth and really plush, generous and silky but also very moreish and juicy. pH 3.6, TA 5.7 g/l,

2y 9m ago

 Ken Gargett, Wine Writer (Australia)  tasted  1 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  8 wines 

Chateau Rayas 1989 – Legendary wine and this showed exactly why. For me, the wine of the day. Over the years, I have marginally preferred the 1990, but it has always been so close and today, this was utterly seductive and enticing. Truly stunning wine. Complex, fragrant, elegant and yet powerful. So supple and textured. Black cherries, cloves, earth notes all combined. Such length. I found this absolutely glorious (as did almost everyone), though our friend with his preference for young Burgundy was not convinced, declaring that in Burgundian terms, this was an okay Premier Cru at best. Wine, being such a subjective topic, means that every opinion should be given equal respect – even when it is completely wrong, as it is here. 100.

2y 11m ago

 Andrew Caillard MW, Wine Writer (Australia)  tasted  1 wines  from  Château Climens . In a tasting of  32 wines 

Château Palmer 2018 / 100 points / Deep colour intense dark cherry, black currant fruits with mocha espresso notes. Amazingly powerful and expressive wine with deep set blackcurrant pastille fruits, richly concentrated graphite tennins. Incredible balance and mineral length. Superb density and complexity. The wine of the vintage?

3y 3m ago

Incorrect Information
If you found some information that is wrong, let us know


We recommend you to share few minutes for watching the following video instructions of how to use the Tastingbook. This can provide you a comprehensive understanding of all the features you can find from this unique service platform.

This video will help you get started

Taste wines with the Tastingbook

Create Your wine cellar on 'My Wines'

Explore Your tasted wines library

Administrate Your wine world in Your Profile

Type a message ...
Register to Tastingbook
Register now, it's fast, easy and totally free. No commitments, only enjoyments.